Karpenter vs Cluster Autoscaler: Which Kubernetes Autoscaling Tool Is Right for You?
Karpenter vs Cluster Autoscaler: Which Kubernetes Autoscaling Tool Is Right for You?
Blog Article
Bernetess has streamlined how we execute and scale workloads. But overseeing cluster optimization — more so at scale — tends to be complicated. Karpenter vs Cluster Autoscaler offer particular utility for dynamically managing compute resources.
Both aim at a common objective — automating your cluster’s node scaling — but adopt very different strategies. In the subsequent sections, we will analyze how they function, their primary distinguishing features, and the contexts in which one alternative is more advantageous than another.
What is Cluster Autoscaler ?
Cluster Autoscaler (CA) is an offere auto-scaling component of Kubernetes. It has existed for some time and is well supported by cloud providers such as AWS, GCP, and Azure, given its development and maintenance by members of the Kubernetes SIG Autoscaling group.
CA functions by observing unschedulable pods in your cluster. For example, if there are resources lacking to place some pods, it attempts to scale up your node groups (qui usually are set in your cloud provider’s auto-scaling groups or managed node groups). It also has the capability to downscale when nodes are underutilized.
Cluster Autoscaler's Advantageous Features :
— Goes without saying, it is tried and true across different environments.
– As it is closely integrated with managed Kubernetes services like EKS, GKE, AKS.
– Serves a variety of instances in a single node group.
Adjustable with node group labels and taints.
Cons :
1. Slow provisioning : relies on cloud provider ASG mechanisms.
2. Requires pre-defined instance types and node group configs.
3. Less flexibility for dynamic workloads and on-demand scaling.
What Is Karpenter ?
Karpenter, AWS’s new autoscaler, is open source and not limited to the AWS environment. Its philosophy differs from others in that it does not scale node groups. Karpenter provisions nodes on-demand, individually, to meet the requirements of the pending pods.
Karpenter makes real-time decisions concerning optimal node types that need to be created out of the cloud provider’s APIs. Deciding is based on the specs that are provided by the pods on units like CPU, RAM, topology included within it, and constraints.
Pros of Karpenter :
1. Faster scaling : launches nodes in real time, skipping ASG layer.
2. Dynamically chooses best-fit instance types (e.g., spot and on-demand).
3. Cost-effective due to intelligent rerouting of resources managing bin-packing and consolidation
4. Uses minimal upfront configuration
Cons
1. Still relatively new, especially outside AWS
2. Requires access to cloud APIs and specific IAM permissions.
3. Behavior can be more difficult to forecast if accustomed to traditional autoscaling.
When to Use Cluster Autoscaler
Cluster Autoscaler is a solid choice if :
1. You are using managed K8s services along with conservative scaling.
Assuming you already set up node groups with instance caps.
You have predictable and stable workloads.
You appreciate wide community support alongside product maturity.
When to Use Karpenter
Karpenter works best with :
Cost-effective Spot instances used in optimized scenarios.
Easier infrastructure management without groups of nodes to supervise.
Elastic platforms on AWS that are cost-sensitive.
Easily, quickly provisioned platforms unbound by precise workload requirements.
Can you use both ?
Yes, but proceed with care.
Some teams apply Cluster Autoscaler for base capacity with steady, low-priority workloads and switch to Karpenter for burst-capacity used with unpredictable, compute-heavy jobs. This model can be effective if carefully tuned, but it increases complexity in management and scheduling.
Final Thoughts from Kapstan
We interface with teams scaling Kubernetes clusters within high-performance, cloud-native environments, and at Kapstan we recommend :
Utilize Cluster Autoscaler if you're just starting your autoscaling journey or operating on multiple cloud providers.
Karpenter comes into play when you're on AWS and seeking precise control, speedier scaling, and heightened cost efficiency.
Your workloads, preferred cloud services, and operational priorities ultimately guide your choice. We’re glad to support you with benchmarks or assistance designing an autoscaling strategy that scales with your team's needs.
Searching for ways to improve the optimization on your Kubernetes clusters ?
We at Kapstan make it our business to alleviate pain for engineering teams tasked with building and maintaining cloud-native scalable systems. We've got your back. Report this page